party shout

I have a buddy who thinks he can hook me up with a 40% discount on Lenovo, which has narrowed my laptop search considerably. With prices before discount, the choices are,

Lenovo ThinkPad x100e ~$500
http://www.engadget.com/2010/03/30/lenovo-thinkpad-x100e-review/
http://www.laptopmag.com/review/lenovo-thinkpad-x100e.aspx

Basically, a very nice netbook with an 11.6" screen.

Lenovo ThinkPad Edge 14 ~$700
http://www.laptopmag.com/review/laptops/lenovo-thinkpad-edge-14.aspx

Well-reviewed, cheap biz laptop. A bit underpowered.

Lenovo ThinkPad T410i ~$900
http://www.laptopmag.com/review/laptops/lenovo-thinkpad-t410.aspx (Review of similar T410)

A bit more powerful and a bit more robust but not much.

Any thoughts? Does anyone besides Zach still own a PC?

eli.pousson posted about 1 year ago

sweet dude.

You still doing design, or is most of your day in google docs / microsoft word? I am currently running adobe softs from 3 versions ago. my biggest processor hog is compilation time, and the number of safari windows that I need open to various API documentation. other than that I am not really hardware bound.

my biggest hardware bounds are:

1. my laptop harddrive dies once a year on average. I am now using an SSD, and it is fucking amazing. When these are standard, peoples minds will be blown. However, it cost more than some of the computers on your list. Also, I am a non standard user in a lot of ways, I don't treat my computer with the respect that it should get. Mine is a kingston SSD-Now V, with 128GB. Highly recommended, now in the 300 dollar range.

2. Screen size. After working on a 24in screen all day at work, my laptop screen feels kinda cramped. I can't have 2-3 docs open side by side, and working on programming with the editor in one window and the API in another sorta sucks.

3. Battery Life. I am on my second battery, but the first one lasted a few years. that was nice.

4. Part / repair manual availability. So far I have done the following repairs on my laptop:
- new fan
- 4 new harddrives (replaced the optical disk when it died too)
- new ram (my ram died, and wrote corrupted data all over the hard drive)
- new keyboard, I blew out the last one playing far cry 2 and pressing control-z really hard.

I know you are going lenovo, because of your discount, but I am pushing hard for you to look into the aftermarket parts now so that you know where to go when things go south. Also, I imagine the lower end ones will have more integrated components, so it will be like, "you need a new keyboard, well you are going to have to replace the wifi card too".

too much? not enuff?

JonBro posted about 1 year ago

Second Jonbro's suggestion about aftermarket parts. Most stuff can be replaced or upgraded off the shelf. I've slowly been scrapping my Alienware for parts as the chassis is identical to my current notebook.

If that's not the kind of ownership experience you're looking for, invest in a warranty because chances are high that something will break.

I seem to recall Lenovos in general having a pretty good reputation on reliability and durabilityThe Thinkpad Edge 14 has some pretty solid stats for the price, as long as you're not using it as a home entertainment center or doing any gaming. I would NOT recommend trying gaming or any sort of 3d stuff w/ an integrated graphics card.

Zach posted about 1 year ago

I'm mostly web surfing and writing right now, although my current computer chokes a bit on all the big RW2 files from my new camera. I'm interested in installing an SSD, do you know are there limits on what you need to put that into a laptop?

Screen size is def a concern with the Lenovo ThinkPad x100e. We have talked about a projector for the house, or maybe a real big flat screen monitor. Not sure about that one.

My last Lenovo battery was not bad, although it was pretty useless after 2.5 years or so.

The service was great for my last Lenovo, when it was under warranty. Right after the warranty expired, I successfully replaced a fan, but in attempting to replace a power jack a year later, I broke the motherboard. That was a bit too much, so the computer continues to sit at home waiting for me to figure out what to do with it.

Both the x100e and the Edge 14 are pretty new models, so I'm not sure what they'll be like in the long term.

eli.pousson posted about 1 year ago

Damn Eli, I was sitting on that post for like an hour.

Also, this might be extravagant, but the x300 looks like it has enough bells and whistles to last for several years:

http://www.laptopmag.com/review/laptops/lenovo-thinkpad-x300.aspx?page=1

Zach posted about 1 year ago

Whew! And a price to match. I was thinking to try to keep this one under $1,000 if I could.

eli.pousson posted about 1 year ago

my current computer chokes a bit on all the big RW2 files from my installing an SSD, do you know are there limits on what you need to put that into a laptop

don't know what you mean by this. Your computer should do the opposite of choke if it has an SSD in it. My cold boot time has gone from over 1 minute to under 10 seconds after getting an SSD. The only size limits on SSD are that they need to be the same form factor as whatever the current drive in your computer is.

I am also a year behind on what the current tech is with these things, but when I bought mine there was a significant difference between the intel x-series (which mine is an OEM of) and everything else. The other drives were way fucking slow, which is one of the primary reasons to move to SSD. I think that OCZ has worked out some of their issues, and put out competitive SSDs on the market, but I am not sure.

oh, wait, I guess you mean moving RW2 files from a camera to your laptop. So you are moving from a camera SSD to your laptops HDD over USB right? This is probably more a fault of the low speed of the cameras SSD than anything else. Not all SSDs are speedy.

JonBro posted about 1 year ago

Oops, sorry dude. That was a typo. It should read, "my current computer chokes a bit on all the big RW2 files from my new camera." Lightroom takes a while to start and takes a long time to display any of the large files.

eli.pousson posted about 1 year ago

you must login to post